pranshuchittoraop3 hours ago
I am the author of this post. Looks like OpenCode fans / team is not happy with this post coming on the first page of HN. It has already been flagged by many. I never ask for upvotes, but would be great if you can upvote it. Thanks!
an0malous16 minutes ago
Oh they’re a YC company: https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/opencode
ShowalkKama3 hours ago
The title should say "OpenCode Console" not "OpenCode".
yorwba3 hours ago
How did you determine that it has been "flagged by many"?
xendo2 hours ago
It's clearly heavily down voted, just look at when it was added, how many points it has and its relative position.
throwoutway24 minutes ago
You cant downvote HN posts (comments you can)
an0malous11 minutes ago
They presumably meant that it’s been downranked relative to what you’d expect from a post with that many upvotes in that short of a time frame. Hundreds of upvotes in a few hours is usually a top 5 post
_fw11 minutes ago
Afaik flagging acts like a super-downvote as far as the algorithm is concerned
pranshuchittoraop3 hours ago
The post was visible when I am logged in. But when I opened the /newest page on incognito the post wasn't there.
senordevnyc3 hours ago
It’s #14 on homepage when not logged in, same as when logged in.
pranshuchittoraop2 hours ago
Now it is
trollbridge2 hours ago
Then next time do a less clickbait-y title: OpenCode had a leak of API keys for their service that is similar to OpenRouter; this does not affect most users.
tekacsan hour ago
It's a little more than that. It seems that keys for OpenAI / Anthropic APIs that were STORED on OpenCode's OpenRouter-like backend got leaked – which additionally means that OpenCode has no ability to refund people for their losses.
Ciantic3 hours ago
I think every API key system should have endpoint "invalidate_api_key" this way whitehat hackers or the party who stored them could invalidate all keys in the case they leak. Now it is race against the time, and everybody got email, and everyone must act themselves.
Tiberium3 hours ago
It actually is a thing, although indirectly in a hacky way! If you push keys from GitHub secret scanning partners to a public repo or a gist, they get sent to the partner who (usually) instantly revoke them. So if you want to help someone, just make a public gist with the key and delete it like 15 seconds later, it'll be enough.
https://docs.github.com/en/code-security/reference/secret-se... has a table with the active partners
Ciantic3 hours ago
Only responsible thing in this case would have been for OpenCode people to invalidate all keys. But I guess it is not that straightforward if Anthropic/OpenAI etc don't have endpoint for it.
ameliaquining3 hours ago
There's no self-serve endpoint, but OpenCode could send the inference providers the leaked keys and ask for them to be revoked, which is a thing the inference providers can do. It's possible that this'll happen, apparently remediation is still in progress.
orfan hour ago
That just turns a credential leak into a denial of service - one that can be triggered from anywhere.
shepherdjerred39 minutes ago
In this case you'd probably prefer your key to be disabled rather than spending $$$ on tokens for everyone else
orf36 minutes ago
Think that through - the person who stole the key has the decision to use it or revoke it through this hypothetical system.
If they are acting maliciously, they will take the choice that most hurts you and/or benefits them.
If the key is useless to them and revoking it hurts you, then they would do that.
If the key wasn’t useless to them, then… they would just use it and not revoke it?
flaunf221an hour ago
Not any more than any other public endpoint service exposes. This revocation endpoint can be protected by auth too. Use API key that you're revoking in auth.
orfan hour ago
How does that make any sense?
flaunf22144 minutes ago
I see now from another comment you thought about denial of service for service that leaked key. And I thought about mass leak resulting in DDOS onto API provider. Wrong guess from me.
max__devan hour ago
Yes. Is this a bad thing?
orfan hour ago
Of course it is? A key for some weather API getting leaked isn’t the end of the world, but having it revoked and breaking your weather app is.
computerex3 hours ago
Why are my API keys in the workspace exposed? Does OpenCode send my API keys to their backend servers??? Was this a supply chain attack that infected the opencode program itself? What is going on?
ameliaquining3 hours ago
If you use the hosted OpenCode Console and bring your own API keys, then they'd have your keys on their backend servers.
InsideOutSantaan hour ago
The announcement is needlessly confusing, but if you only use the CLI, you're not affected. There is no supply chain attack.
pranshuchittoraop3 hours ago
They need to explain this, by releasing a detailed RCA.
djchen3 hours ago
Is my understanding correct that this only affected some OpenCode Zen users who stored their (BYOK) API keys from Anthropic/Google/OpenAI?
In essence they used OpenCode Zen similar to OpenRouter, where you can BYOK or use theirs and be charged token rates.
nightpool3 hours ago
That's the only known impact so far. But we don't know the details of how these keys were exposed, so it's not entirely clear why or how "only keys" might have been affected
jchw3 hours ago
I don't use OpenCode but I would like to know who this impacts. Surely people who are just using OpenCode locally with their own credentials wouldn't be impacted, right? This sounds like something where you have a hosted service and you put your keys into that. Not saying this isn't bad, but it isn't clear and they're not sharing any information.
hahajk3 hours ago
This appears to affect users of Opencode Console, which appears to be an Openrouter-type thing?
https://dev.opencode.ai/console/
It's actually kinda hard to figure out what it is. But it does appear to be different that the CLI
From https://opencode.ai/v2/docs#connect :
> If you’d like easy access to all the best coding models you can try out OpenCode Console.
neya3 hours ago
Turns out even if you used credentials locally, you could've have been impacted as the .env files were also consumed by the agents. This is from some comments on Reddit / Google, so take it with a grain of salt.
oldfuture3 hours ago
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50108261
that's why virustotal was flagging it then
ameliaquining3 hours ago
It sounds like only a hosted service was compromised, not the open source OpenCode binary that users run on their own machines. So this wouldn't explain that.
monster_truck3 hours ago
Wait, is the openchode hack the cause of all the people complaining about their OAI usage getting drained/vanishing at alarming rates? That's pretty funny ngl.
The way some of this place's employees post and act online, can't say I feel all that bad.
fleshers4 hours ago
I’m a bit confused by the wording here, does it mean the credentials were hacked and then used to perform a mass distillation campaign?
pranshuchittoraop3 hours ago
It triggers me when these companies think that users are fool. I would have appreciated them, if they have disclosed things more transparently.
ipsum23 hours ago
"mass distillation campaign" there's no public evidence of this. I wonder what OpenCode/Anomaly has, would be an interesting postmortem.
vdfs3 hours ago
Obviously they don't want to share details because it's ongoing
[deleted]3 hours agocollapsed
odo12423 hours ago
Yes
pranshuchittoraop3 hours ago
[dead]
rozenmdan hour ago
@dang this title needs updating: "OpenCode Console hacked: User credentials leaked"
The opencode CLI has no impact.
Rapzidan hour ago
It doesn't say the CLI was hacked does it?
qlte33 minutes ago
OpenCode = OpenCode CLI to most people (as seen in the dozens of comments making that assumption in this thread)
[deleted]an hour agocollapsed
verbo_villain3 hours ago
So are people going to wake up and see their Anthropic, openAI, etc accounts drained?
jprokay132 hours ago
I saw the email this morning from OpenCode about my key being compromised alongside an email from Anthropic stating that I used up my $20 in API credits for the month. I hope they built something cool with those tokens!
pranshuchittoraop2 hours ago
Yes
hypfer28 minutes ago
They have shown so so so many times that their culture is not aligned with trustworthy software. Yet people keep using it.
It's not like there wouldn't be any other harnesses either. Just switch to literally anything else please.
ssernikk25 minutes ago
Can you elaborate on that?
thway152690372 hours ago
Was it opencode who bragged about their vibecoding tokenmaxxing attitude or I'm mixing them with someone else?
bakugo2 hours ago
Honestly, who isn't bragging about their vibecoding tokenmaxxing attitude nowadays?
pranshuchittoraop2 hours ago
Awaiting for detailed breakdown of the incident. I am more interested in knowing , how can a distillation attack leak / expose credentials.
MisterMunchkin3 hours ago
It’s fascinating that tokens are so valuable that people are spending so much time and effort hacking to obtain API keys.
qlte22 minutes ago
API keys have been routinely stolen in mass automated attacks for malicious usage long before LLMs even existed
nacs3 hours ago
They might have spent next to 0 time actually 'hacking' - they may have just told Opencode to hack Opencode website and let it run for hours or days till it succeeded.
pranshuchittoraop2 hours ago
The tokens of frontier are valuable...
searealist3 hours ago
> security breach
> related to a large scale distillation attack
I'm not sure how this adds up. I could understand if this impacted their uptime, but not security.
Are they actually saying a bunch of credentials were stolen and are being used for distillation?
pranshuchittoraop2 hours ago
Yes, they think we are foooool
yipinwong2 hours ago
wtf was I getting many use OpenCode on OpenCode cloud emails last few days. Were they set up so that hackers can get more info?
90210072 hours ago
latchkey2 hours ago
the ux is kind of crazy.
you login to their website, and you are presented with a list of providers where you can click and add your provider api key.
how the key is stored on the backend isn't clear, but it is akin to handing your password or if you know crypto, your private key, to someone and letting them store it for you.
from what i can tell, there are no links within the console to a ToS, Privacy policy or anything else. there are no warnings or documentation about how they store your keys.
someone else in this thread linked to this issue, but this comment is especially insane given that i can't find any privacy policy or tos for the console.
https://github.com/anomalyco/opencode/issues/10416#issuecomm...
InsideOutSantaan hour ago
FWIW, OpenRouter has the exact same feature.
latchkeyan hour ago
and their TOS/Privacy policies are equally light on details.
vinni24 hours ago
But isn’t OpenCode open source why does it need credentials.
progval3 hours ago
For the inference APIs, which need to bill users. It's unclear why OpenCode's servers (presumably) had access to the API credentials.
trollbridge2 hours ago
Because people cut and pasted them in.
himata41133 hours ago
They function similar to openrouter BYOK.
dist-epoch3 hours ago
Maybe they support cloud agents.
kelvinjps103 hours ago
opencode go and zen?
rvz3 hours ago
Looking forward to the post-mortem of this incident.
pranshuchittoraop2 hours ago
Yes, I am interested in how a distillation attack can leak credentials...
preommr3 hours ago
Why are the comments pointing out there were warning signs early on being downvoted/flagged?
I looked at the linked comments, and they seem valid. I mean I dont want to go full tinfoil hat here, but what's the deal? Some people just really like opencode or something?
c-hendricksan hour ago
All the comments I've seen about warning signs point to opencode the cli, where this is about one of opencode's hosted services.
InsideOutSantaan hour ago
Because they're unrelated to this incident.
jchw3 hours ago
I think it may just be bad automated flagging. I vouch'd them since they don't really seem to violate any rules/guidelines (right?)
himata41133 hours ago
Indeed. I've seen it happen before and it appears that they have automatic downvoting based on some criteria, possibly just some classifier. I've attributed it to some bot attack before, but it's a bit too common now.
dylan6043 hours ago
Why does it being common downplay the bot attack to you? As time goes on, I'd assume bots activity to increase. I do not see it ever going away.
himata41133 hours ago
bots get caught and downvoting requires reputation.
TZubiri2 hours ago
4 days ago red flags were raised
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50075319
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50060694
what’s interesting is that all those efforts that go into sandboxing through virtualization wouldn’t have helped here. But the solutions that proxy the api keys and hide them from agents might have worked as a defense in depth.
of course any sensible engineer that uninstalled this 6 months ago and used codex and claude code directly also avoided this, gg
nrmitchi30 minutes ago
What the the purpose of this comment? Neither of those "red flags" you linked to are related (one is about config loading precedence, and the other is about Codex CLI, which is completely a completely different product and development team.
Exterior-compliance proxies, yes, are a good thing; but are also completely unrelated to the fact that OpenCode's hosted solution, that requires having credentials in some fashion, was popped.
Shitting on anyone who uses OpenCode (rather than your preferred vendor-specific product) as not being "sensible" is also completely out of hand and unnecessary.
pranshuchittoraop4 hours ago
From OpenCode Team
---
Hi, We identified unauthorized access to a legacy system that we were in the process of decommissioning. Third party provider keys (eg OpenAI, Anthropic) saved in your workspace may have been exposed. Please revoke and replace those keys through the relevant provider’s dashboard, update any applications using them, and review recent usage for unexpected activity.
We’re sorry this happened and will follow up with any updates.
sebastiansm73 hours ago
We were planning to fix our vibecoded mess.
TZubiri2 hours ago
it’s funny how no one ever announces their critical vulns with “we have been hacked, you should uninstall our software and use something else”, at some point in the severity of the vuln that should be the conclusion, but no one ever says it
qlte27 minutes ago
> uninstall our software
This was a leak of keys added in a web UI
vc143 hours ago
[flagged]
bewareofscams4 hours ago
I told you so: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49243119
Me, 68 days ago:
> Beware of the author of tweet, who happens to be author of OpenCode - OpenCode will leak all your data to themselves and to shady 3rd parties. Author feigned ignorance and never fixed the issue. OpenCode among other harnesses is the shadiest of all.
lukewarm7072 hours ago
"when challenged about sending data to openrouter without listing it as a 3rd party processor they offered a dismissive response. the same with running prompts through cloudflare. seems trivial, but signifies general disinterest in security."
I did have an account but moved off for security reasons.
lousken3 hours ago
If i dont use any of their models nor i am signed in, is that a problem? i dont see anything in wireshark except for models.opencode.ai
tadasv2 hours ago
This is one of the reasons I don't trust opencode. It looked very nice on paper when it first came out and there were no alternatives. However, today I'd probably stick with simple pi setup (not sure how much better than opencode, but it looks like they don't have all this cloud stuff) or just use one of the big tech agents and call it a day.
neya3 hours ago
Damn, that sucks. I didn't know OpenCode was this bad when it came to privacy.
whisper492 hours ago
[dead]