Hacker News

more likely "...a furlong and more" ... no meters that time :}

"They couldn't hit an elephant at this distance" - last words of Major General John Sedgwick, American Civil War.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Sedgwick

"Let me show you its features".

I hate this meme. Someone says "think about what you are doing prideful fool". And the other person still decides to use lethal force. That is diabolical, not funny.

Please don't censor yourself. It should be possible for you to share a video of something without that meaning you support it. You probably live in a country that has free speech? Use it.

I would like to see a video of a trebuchet. Modern or not.

https://old.reddit.com/r/aoe2/comments/dncow5/fully_function...

I don't get the nitpicking here. Scientifically correct, since circumstantial. Meteor is also possible, but very unlikely.

The probability regimes in which science is dealing often only leave marginal room for alternative explanations.

I parsed it as ((mass grave containing 9 skeletons) dated to the early 1300s) && ((5 skeletons) dated to the 1300s).

As in, the grave itself was dated, and 5 of the 9 skeletons found inside were also individually dated to roughly the same century. Maybe the other 4 were not tested, or turned out to have been buried at a later date.

I hate to contradict you, but it seems like a tautology.

> We can rule out Warwolf

Can we? That Wikipedia page is inconclusive, and thus article says:

During Edward I’s 1304 siege of the castle, English forces deployed the recently invented trebuchet, a weapon first documented in the 12th century. A cousin to the catapult, trebuchets were capable of hurling boulders weighing more than 100 kilograms hundreds of meters. One at Stirling, dubbed “War Wolf,” “was the biggest trebuchet ever built at that point,” Buckberry says. Eyewitness accounts confirm the giant siege engine was used during the 1304 battle, tearing through two stone walls “as an arrow would fly through a piece of cloth.”

Accounts of the battle don’t mention any trebuchet casualties. But Buckberry says Skeleton 150’s injuries strongly suggest at least one defender was hit from behind by a flying boulder, launched by War Wolf or one of the other siege engines arrayed outside Stirling Castle’s walls. “It’s a huge amount of energy delivered in milliseconds,” Waltenberger says. “In skeletons from past times you rarely see this.”

Indeed, I am sure there are other mechanisms that could cause similar trauma.

Unlikely, as a regular slow crush gives very different injuries compared to a high velocity impact.

> Hope he died quickly, instead of having to deal with the pain of multiple bones crushing

from the article: “skull broken in 61 places”

Doubt you’d stay conscious long enough to notice

Instant unconsciousness. Hopefully he didn't wake up.

War… war never changes.

Well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Is_a_Racket

From 1935. And he was not the first one to point that out either.

I actually think that thanks to the internet, we expose many more criminal build ups towards warfare nowadays than before.

Well I call you a WIMP! I want to go by literally shitting blood in an agonising pain an fever for weeks on end, like most people in these campaigns often faced their demise: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dysentery

Actually, you know what, I think you might have a point there. I take back ky harsh words.

Catapults store energy using elastic deformation, like a bow; counterweight trebuchets store energy using gravity.

Didn't the Romans have something similar?

What do you expect - it came in like a wrecking ball

Didn’t feel it though, cuz he was stoned.