Hacker News

glimshe
Robert Duvall has died nytimes.com

ZoomZoomZooman hour ago

Don't know about the States, but across the pond from there, THX 1138 is not as well known as it probably deserves. I hope the public here can appreciate this Sci-Fi movie and Duvall is great there.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/THX_1138

jhbadgeran hour ago

It's known over here (to the degree that it is at all) for being the source of the THX name that Lucas later used for his digital sound system. But the movie is interesting in itself as an early pre-fame Lucas movie.

tokyobreakfast3 hours ago

He was very underrated in Falling Down, a sleeper of a film everyone should see at least once.

StoneAndSky2 hours ago

I don't remember it being a "sleeper"; I recall it stirring quite a bit of controversy at the time. It came out in the pre-Columbine "Going Postal" era. But agreed: it's worth a watch.

browningstreet2 hours ago

It’s a smaller movie, given the talent involved, but very interesting. The controversy undermined the viability of its popular legacy.

Kind of like Passengers (half kidding, but the controversy on this one always felt like an inadvertent bend of timeliness).

ngcazzan hour ago

You made me curious, but there are like 5 different films with that title - which one are you referring to?

CharlesW21 minutes ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falling_Down. It was the #1 movie in the U.S. for a couple weeks after release, made for $25M and grossed $96M.

flanbiscuit19 minutes ago

The Michael Douglas one I’m assuming where Duvall was the cop

https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0106856/

dcrazyan hour ago

I was very surprised to learn that Joel Schumacher directed Falling Down.

Waterluvian2 hours ago

Falling Down is a brilliant film. I think Duvall’s sober, gentle, unfazed detective is exactly what makes it work.

The entire movie D-FENS is running into people who trigger him or push back and justify his rage. So the whole time you’re rooting for him. He’s the protagonist! And then you get to the end and the detective just doesn’t give him the same response. But you never worry that Duvall is about to be a victim. And I think it’s very difficult to portray a character who is seasoned, gentle, grandfatherly, but doesn’t come off in the slightest as prey.

The movie is a bit of a gut punch because I think it does encourage you to cheer for him sticking it to The Man and the Nazis and the corporations, only to realize ,alongside Douglas, that “I’m the bad guy?”

unethical_ban24 minutes ago

Spoiler!!

D-Fens was mostly right with his anger. Just turned out he never knew how to control it and was an abusive husband, too.

hearsathought2 hours ago

If we are talking underrated films he was in, my choice would be Deep Impact.

detourdogan hour ago

The Apostle is a great movie of his one doesn't hear mentioned a lot.

[deleted]an hour agocollapsed

SirFattyan hour ago

Like the other sleeper, Apocalypse Now. :-D

helterskelter2 hours ago

Don't forget Network.

stronglikedan2 hours ago

> sleeper

Obligatory, I do not think it means what you think it means.

When that film first debuted, you couldn't throw a rock without hitting someone who knew of it.

threethirtytwo2 hours ago

We're old. When younger people uncover the greatness of an older movie, from there perspective it's equivalent to uncovering a sleeper.

soupfordummies2 hours ago

It's just memory-holed to the point of being purposefully buried at this point.

This comment and a similar one on reddit are the only times I've even seen it mentioned anywhere (IRL or otherwise) in 10+ years

Markoff2 hours ago

I wanted to write RIP Prendergast, but since you mentioned it I put it here, whole movie flew under radar, masterpiece.

brightball2 hours ago

seanalltogether2 hours ago

My dad was a big fan of westerns, so Lonesome Dove was a big deal in our house when I was a kid. Sometimes I think about showing them to my son, but I know there's no way he'll have the patience to sit through it all. I'm worried that I might not have the patience either anymore.

Steve6an hour ago

I recently read the book for the first time. Fantastic story! The best western I've ever read. Then I watched the miniseries with my wife (also for the first time). Westerns aren't her favorite, but she loved it too. Robert Duvall and Tommy Lee Jones were incredible, the whole cast did a great job, and the costumes and scenery were beautiful. We still make jokes about "We don't rent pigs." :)

We only watched season 1 because that's the one based on the original Lonesome Dove book. They make some changes, but generally only one that makes the show easier to follow. I'd highly recommend anyone to watch it. If you stick with only season 1 it tells a complete story and it's not too long of a commitment. It has everything.

RIP Duvall. You've had many roles, but this is the one I'll remember you for.

garbawarb41 minutes ago

Would you recommend the book or series?

ScotterC27 minutes ago

The book will not let you down

stephc_int132 hours ago

Sad that even obituaries are written by AI these days...

CharlesW18 minutes ago

These are written years in advance. It's vanishingly unlikely that this was AI-generated or AI-edited.

beej71an hour ago

No kidding. He deserves better.

mbowcut2an hour ago

Loved him in Secondhand Lions.

sgt2 hours ago

RIP Duval - he inspired me, like he inspired many others. I can't explain why, but his demeanour and sensibility. Recently watched Open Range. Need to watch more of his westerns.

ReptileManan hour ago

RIP Duval - he inspired me too. Recently watched Apocalypse Now.

partiallypro3 hours ago

He has too many great films to list, but one I really like that is lesser by him known nowadays is "Secondhand Lions."

robertcope2 hours ago

Agreed, absolutely fantastic movie.

justin662 hours ago

Peculiar to think he was already forty when THX 1138 came out, 55 (!) years ago.

[deleted]2 hours agocollapsed

55556242 hours ago

"Atchley do you realize that several Marines were killed by the Japanese at Pearl Harbor while taking craps?" "No, sir." "A fighting man must be vigilant to surprise attack no matter where he is. The survival of our nation depends on the readiness of Marines all over the world. Also more importantly, you only wiped yourself twice - grossly insufficient. Right now, germs with names you can't even pronounce are preparing to launch a devastating attack that will render you helpless in the defense of your country... Do you read me?" (The Great Santini)

pdonis2 hours ago

Classic. I also love the scene where he tells the squadron of which he's just become CO that they should think of him as God.

NickC25an hour ago

Thank you for your work, Don Hagen.

ChrisArchitect2 hours ago

dangan hour ago

Thanks - we've switched to that from https://www.newsweek.com/entertainment/hollywood-legend-robe... above.

xqcgrek22 hours ago

why do people venerate actors?

asveikau2 hours ago

People see them on the screen so often they think they know them. I guess the term "parasocial relationship" has been common in the last few years to describe this.

I guess for actors and other types of artist specifically, people relate strongly to the work. It can form the basis for life memories. You remember where you were when you heard a song or saw a movie.

Rooster612 hours ago

Because the service they render brings joy and entertainment to a large multitude of people. It is a higher visibility job than most, and is largely an individual contribution in and of the service they provide

slibhb2 hours ago

Why do people like fictional narrative so much? I'm not sure why, other than some platitude like "forming narratives is how people understand the world". But I'm not sure why it follows that fictional narratives are so important to us.

BLKNSLVRan hour ago

Because a good story scratches something that's deep and hard to reach.

Because fiction allows an escape from the drudgery that real life can so often be.

Because sometimes fiction is required to inspire us as to what we consider possible in life.

curiousObject2 hours ago

Actors express the human condition, and that’s more difficult than you think.

To pretend to be a person that you are not, on demand, for months on end, is hard and it demands great empathy and skill.

bdcravens2 hours ago

The same reason they venerate anyone: common positive experiences.

beej71an hour ago

They don't, in particular. They venerate people who have done amazing things.

bubblewand2 hours ago

Very-publicly doing work that lots of people enjoy tends to have that effect.

browningstreet2 hours ago

Because they became part of our stories through performance and iterations. We experienced their work.

twoodfin2 hours ago

Also, stories and those who tell them have been kind of a big deal for us homo sapiens now north of 50,000 years.

paulcole2 hours ago

why do people venerate computer scientists?

markus_zhang3 hours ago

Jeez I thought he was long gone. The family will remember your service, Mr. Hagen.

bdcravens2 hours ago

He's one of those actors that if you told me he was dead, I wouldn't have been surprised, but then you go to the theater and in some random role, there he is.

hinkley2 hours ago

It really messes with me though when someone dies before their last film came out. I watched that Batman movie with a knot in my stomach the whole time.

“He’s so good. But he’s gone. WTF.”

I don’t recall who now but there was some actor whose last film came out more than a year after he died, and that felt messed up and I can’t articulate why.

bdcravens2 hours ago

Paul Walker is probably the most recent one to fall into that category. I believe his character will be in the next Fast and the Furious movie, but it'll be a CGI role (with family members standing in as the body/face they CG-enhance)

FreakLegion2 hours ago

Brandon Lee and Paul Walker come to mind. A year delay or more isn't rare, I don't think.

bdcravens2 hours ago

River Phoenix had a role (Dark Blood) that he OD'd while filming, and it was put on hold, but then eventually finished and released 19 years later.

hn-front (c) 2024 voximity
source